What the service does to them
One letter: a trailing capital Z becomes an explicit offset of zero. Everything else is handed to the standard reader as it stands.
So a lower-case z is refused, since the rewriting never reaches it. A moment with no zone at all is kept as written, and a date on its own — no time, no zone — is taken as midnight.
Which refusal catches a missing zone
An edge without a zone is refused, but where depends on the other edge.
Where one edge carries a zone and the other does not, comparing the two for order is itself what raises: the pair never reaches the test that comparison was written for, nor the frames.
Where neither carries a zone, nothing in that comparison objects to it, and a pair in order goes on to the frames — where the refusal comes instead.
What the asker is told
Each of these comes back as a bad request carrying the words of whatever raised. The asker reads the complaint of the comparison, or of the standard reader, or of the frame loader — not one message the service writes for the field.
Related
- Asking for a replay from outside
- Where a replay's bars come from
- What stopping the replay listener does
Source evidence
---
row: P14-01
baseline: 49aa659
created: 2026-11-08 14:25 UTC
modified: 2026-11-08 15:12 UTC
evidence:
- claim: "A moment ending in a capital Z is rewritten to a zero offset, and any other text is handed to the reader as it stands"
source: "`replay_api.py` 260-262"
- claim: "So a moment with no zone is kept, a date on its own is taken as midnight without one, and a lower-case z is refused"
source: "`replay_api.py` 260-262"
- claim: "One edge carrying a zone and one not raises at the comparison between them, rather than reaching the refusal that comparison is written for"
source: "`replay_api.py` 207, against the refusal at 208-209"
- claim: "Two edges both without a zone are refused where the frames are read"
source: "`load_replay_bars.py` 58-60, reached from `replay_api.py` 211-218"
- claim: "A failure of any of those kinds comes back as a bad request carrying the raiser's own words"
source: "`replay_api.py` 129-130, around the call at 127-128"
---